The Hiring Disconnect: How Companies and Candidates Miss Each Other—and How to Fix It
Hiring is more than just filling a vacancy—it's about building sustainable teams that grow with the business.
As a recruitment consultancy working closely with fast-scaling companies across industries like Quick Commerce, EdTech, GCCs, and Fintech, we at SilverPeople see the hiring process from both sides of the table. And more often than not, we witness how easily companies lose great candidates—and how candidates miss out on the right opportunities—due to common hiring missteps.
Let’s dive into the most prevalent mistakes we see both employers and candidates make—and how to correct them.
Where Companies Go Wrong
-
Rigid Job Descriptions: Many companies approach us with hyper-specific job requirements—exact degrees, years of experience, niche tools expertise. While that’s understandable for some senior roles, overly rigid filters can eliminate skilled, adaptable candidates. We always recommend focusing on skills-based hiring: prioritize capabilities, mindset, and the ability to learn, especially for high-growth sectors.
-
Delayed Hiring Processes: In today's competitive market, top candidates don’t wait. Yet, many businesses still take weeks (sometimes months) to close a role. Delayed feedback loops, endless interview rounds, and poor communication all contribute to lost talent. We work with our clients to streamline their hiring process end-to-end—from shortlisting to final offer—ensuring speed doesn't compromise quality.
-
Weak Employer Branding: Candidates are increasingly researching potential employers—Glassdoor reviews, LinkedIn presence, work culture signals. If your online footprint is outdated or lacks authenticity, you’re already a step behind. As hiring consultants, we help clients strengthen their employer brand, showcase leadership stories, and make culture part of the pitch.
-
Mismatched Expectations: We’ve seen many cases wherenew hires exit within a few months because the job wasn’t what they expected. Clear, transparent JDs, aligned with actual responsibilities, are critical. We work with hiring managers to ensure role clarity and expectation alignment from the start.
-
Poor Candidate Experience: Ghosting applicants, unstructured interviews, and vague feedback damage your reputation in the talent market. A candidate rejected today could be a future fit. Every interaction matters. That’s why we train our clients on offering respectful and consistent communication, regardless of outcome.
Where Job Seekers Go Wrong
-
No Research: Applying blindly to roles without understanding company values or industry context often leads to poor fit. Candidates should view job search as a strategic project. We guide job seekers to explore potential employers deeply before applying or interviewing.
-
Overemphasizing Salary: We get it—compensation matters. But ignoring growth, leadership, and culture often leads to burnout or dissatisfaction. We encourage candidates to think long-term and assess the holistic opportunity a role offers.
-
Undervaluing Transferable Skills: Many candidates only showcase titles and qualifications. But today’s employers value problem-solving, adaptability, and collaboration just as much. We coach candidates on how to highlight these skills in CVs and interviews.
-
Underpreparation: Even great resumes can fall flat in interviews if the candidate hasn’t prepared well. We help candidates by sharing insights on client expectations, common interview questions, and how to ask intelligent questions that show engagement.
SilverPeople – The Hiring Partner
The hiring journey doesn’t have to be broken. At SilverPeople, we act as a strategic bridge—guiding companies to hire smarter and helping candidates land roles that match their goals and values. Avoiding these common mistakes can lead to faster hiring cycles, better retention, and stronger employer-employee partnerships.
Want to avoid these pitfalls in your next hiring campaign or job search? Let SilverPeople—your recruitment consultancy—help you get it right.
